Service user involvement in nursing, midwifery and health visiting research: A review of evidence and practice
Section snippets
What is already known about the topic?
- •
In the UK policy recommends that service users (patients, carers and the public) should be involved in all publicly funded health and social care research.
- •
Involving service users as active partners in research processes can help to achieve better quality research, which might lead to better quality health services. However, little is known about which approaches work best in nursing, midwifery or health visiting research contexts or under what circumstances successful outcomes can be achieved.
What this paper adds
- •
This paper provides an analytical account of service user involvement in the design and undertaking of nursing, midwifery and health visiting research in the UK.
- •
The paper suggests ways for researchers and research organisations to develop their capacity to work with service users. Important issues to consider are diversity, communication, ethics, working relationships, finances, education and training.
About the study
The aim of the study was to inform the NHS Service Delivery and Organisation (SDO) Research and Development Programme about the theory and evidence on service user involvement in the design and undertaking of nursing, midwifery and health visiting research. The team that undertook the work came from a range of academic and NHS research backgrounds; including nursing, mental health, social work, social policy and public involvement. Our different perspectives were helpful for making links to
The scope of the review
The project team aimed to work with members of the service user reference group to make decisions about the scope of the review and to set inclusion criteria. Before we could do this we needed to develop a broad definition of what we meant by ‘service user involvement in nursing, midwifery and health visiting research’. We developed a series of working definitions (see appendix of the full report), using initial sweeps of the literature and consulting with researchers working in the area. From
Synthesis and analysis
We have described our approach to using different methods to analyse and synthesise information from a wide range of sources as a multi-method review. Previously, researchers have developed different methods for synthesising information from diverse sources. We specifically looked at the work of Britten et al. (2002) and Greenhalgh et al. (2004). Although these approaches guided our thinking they did not always seem to fit the purpose of what we were trying to achieve. A review of issues in
The nature of the data
Searches of health and social care electronic databases (listed in Appendix A) identified 2132 publications of which 345 were judged to be relevant based on their titles/abstracts. An annotated bibliography of all documents included in the review is available online as a supplement to the full report (http://www.sdo.lshtm.ac.uk). Library searches for books and chapters revealed a further 25 documents, most of which were only partially relevant to the topic area and to the scope of the review. A
What is known about service user involvement in NM&HV research
The study shows how service user involvement in nursing, midwifery and health visiting research can be conceptualised. It also shows how nursing, midwifery and health visiting research has contributed to different theories and approaches to involving service users and suggests ways of involving service users in the broad ranging contexts of nursing, midwifery and health visiting research. In this paper it is only possible to look at some of the key contextual factors, issues and challenges for
Contextual factors
Service user involvement in research has been influenced by a complex interplay of social and political ideas and movements. Other authors have described these factors so we will only provide a brief overview here and direct the reader to key publications.
- (i)
Consumerism and participation: From the 1980s ideas about consumerism in UK health services have been driven by attempts to meet increasing demands on health services (Segal, 1998). Consumerism has generally been interpreted as patients having
Conceptualisations and approaches
Service user involvement in research has been conceptualised as a hierarchy and as a continuum. The most frequently cited model in the research literature is Arnstein's (1969) ladder of citizen participation. This was developed to represent different levels of control the poor had over decision-making processes in the US. A hierarchical relationship between concepts of patient involvement, participation and partnership has also been perceived in relation to nursing practice (Cahill, 1996). In
Outcomes of involvement
The research literature shows that involving service users in different aspects of the research process is widely thought to be valuable. Yet, without understanding the particular reasons why service users were involved it is difficult to make any judgements about the nature of the outcomes that were achieved.
We found that few published NM&HV studies had a clear rationale or objectives for involving service users. Often, reasons for involvement were described in very general terms. Previous
Capacity to develop research relationships
A range of social, cultural and economic resources is required to support research relationships effectively. Those who fund, lead or otherwise contribute to nursing, midwifery and health visiting research can plan for and address these in a number of ways.
Conclusions
The review brought together disparate information about user involvement in nursing, midwifery and health visiting research using systematic and reproducible methods. Undertaking the national consultation and interviews with project leads was highly beneficial for identifying and interpreting key issues, ideas, suggestions and ways forward. Although these elements of the review were dependant on the experiences and knowledge of members of NM&HV research communities at the time, the information
Acknowledgements
The project was funded by the NHS Service Delivery and Organisation Nursing and Midwifery Subgroup through a process of open tender.
We would like to acknowledge the contribution of members of the service user reference group and their organisations: Age Concern; Association for Improvements in the Maternity Services (AIMS); BLISS—The premature baby charity; British Council for Disabled People; British Heart Foundation; Cancer Research UK; Carers London/UK; Clifford Beers Foundation; Diabetes
References (98)
Voluntariness in clinical research at the end of life
Journal of Pain Symptom Management
(2003)- et al.
The client as educator: learning about mental illness through the eyes of the expert
Nurse Education Today
(2003) - et al.
Consumer involvement in health research: a review and research agenda
Health Policy
(2002) - et al.
Woundcare Research for Appropriate Products (WRAP): validation of the TELER method involving users
International Journal of Nursing Studies
(2004) - et al.
Patient perspectives on participation in a clinical trial of angina management
Applied Nursing Research
(1999) - et al.
Consumer involvement in decisions about what health-related research is funded
Health Policy
(2004) The importance of patient empowerment in health system reform
Health Policy
(1998)- et al.
How to involve hard to reach groups: a consumer-led project with lay carers of people with advanced HIV infection
Public Health
(1997) - Alabaster, E., Allen, D., Fothergill, A., Hanks, C., Hannigan, B., Lowes, L., Lyne, P., Northway, R., Papanikolaou, P.,...
What is consumerism and has it had an impact on health visiting provision? A literature review
Journal of Advanced Nursing
(2001)
A ladder of citizen participation
Journal of the American Institute of Planners (AIP Journal)
The People's Health Service?
Partnerships with service users in interprofessional education for community mental health: a case study
Journal of Interprofessional Care
Consumerism versus empowerment: a principled approach to the involvement of older service users
Policy and Politics
User involvement in research and evaluation: liberation or regulation?
Social Policy & Society
User involvement in research: exploring the challenges
Nursing Times Research
‘Service user’: regressive or liberatory terminology?
Disability and Society
Disabled people, service users, user involvement and representation
Disability & Society
Using meta ethnography to synthesis qualitative research: a worked example
Journal of Health Service Research and Policy
Patient participation: a concept analysis
Journal of Advanced Nursing
Using individualised communication for interviewing people with intellectual disability: a case study of user-centred research
Journal of Intellectual & Developmental Disability
What do I want from health research and researchers when I am a patient?
British Medical Journal
Community development: theoretical and practical issues for community health nursing in Canada
Journal of Advanced Nursing
Practice development: ambiguity in research and practice
Journal of Advanced Nursing
Paternalism in nursing and healthcare: central issues and their relation to theory
Nursing Science Quarterly
Action research from the inside: issues and challenges in doing action research in your own hospital
Journal of Advanced Nursing
Paternalism or partnership?
British Medical Journal
Systematic review of involving patients in the planning and development of health care
British Medical Journal
The politics of participation
A Database of Examples of Consumer Involvement in Research
Capturing users’ experiences of participating in cancer trials
European Journal of Cancer Care
Involving older people in research to examine quality of life in residential aged care
Quality in Ageing
Harnessing expertise: involving peer interviewers in qualitative research with hard-to-reach populations
Health Expectations
Lay perspectives: advantages for health research
British Medical Journal
Researching experiences of cancer: the importance of methodology
European Journal of Cancer Care
Incentives in research: ethical issues
Orthopaedic Nursing
Pedagogy, power and service user involvement
Journal of Psychiatric & Mental Health Nursing
Disseminating the results of participant-focused research
Journal of Transcultural Nursing
Cited by (88)
Public and Patient Engagement
2019, Encyclopedia of Pharmacy Practice and Clinical Pharmacy: Volumes 1-3Patient and public involvement in research published in the British Journal of Occupational Therapy 2015–2021: A scoping review
2023, British Journal of Occupational TherapyDigital midwifery care during the COVID-19 pandemic in Germany—acceptance of mothers
2023, Bundesgesundheitsblatt - Gesundheitsforschung - GesundheitsschutzProduction Dynamics for Life Quality in the Incipient 21st Century
2022, Production Dynamics for Life Quality in the Incipient 21st CenturyWhat motivates informal carers to be actively involved in research, and what obstacles to involvement do they perceive?
2021, Research Involvement and Engagement